Aug 22, 2014
Every day, I try to put aside some time for combing the internet and reading a variety of industry related articles. This week an older article from FireRescue1.com from July of 2012 that former Washington DC fire chief Dennis Rubin reposted called “5 reasons not to merge fire and police” caught my eye. The article presents arguments against combining police and fire departments. I read through the article and was able to draw a parallel between this topic and the argument against merging fire and EMS. Keep in mind that this is in no way a reflection of every single fire-based system on the map. Some do it very well but for each of those effective, progressive fire based EMS systems, I feel like I have found two who do it very poorly or worse, do not understand or care what they are getting into when they take over ambulance response. I invite you to read the full article by clicking here but here are some of the chief’s observations and my thoughts on them. “There are a multitude of examples where communities have fused the police and fire departments into one public safety agency. The motivating logic seems to be that neither department is busy enough to command the tax share needed t operate separate agency. The initial belief is that merging two costly departments into one will create a more efficient department, thereby saving big public bucks.” EMS and fire are often combined for the exact same reason. The fire departments are not busy enough so in theory, combining fire and EMS gives them the ability to handle an additional piece of the public safety workload. The workload that EMS brings in, however, is often ignored or it is not realized to be as involved and time consuming as it is. However, the transition of police duties into the fire and rescue department comes at a steep price that you will not find on a budget line-item spreadsheet. Intangibles such as organizational stress, personnel, resistance, and demoralization of the rank-and-file members of both departments are the major factors that will ensure this type of plan’s failure.” Take a close look at any fire and...
Recent Comments